Alex Bray

FN / Field notes

Evidence used to go cold at the crime scene. Now it goes cold waiting in line.

Field notes3 min read

My colleagues know that I’m a little obsessed with origin stories. I want to know why something started. The original purpose, the first occurrence, or the causal event can tell us a lot about why things are the way that they are.

So we should take a look at the old-school crime scene: Prints of value sitting on every surface? We’ll need to clean that up when we’re done here. Gobs of DNA scattered about? Not sure what that is. Ignore it. Blood on the floor? Don’t slip. Let it dry up while us detectives think through these hunches.

The focus for the past several decades has been on preventing physical evidence from decaying.

However, even after realizing the value of that evidence and successfully acquiring it, there is still a risk of destruction. Those of us who have been in the field for a while have heard far too many times; “we only have enough material for 1 DNA test” or “the tech used the wrong chemical solution on that item with the print on it”.

Cool. Thanks.

But here comes great news! It’s digital evidence and his buddy, bit-for-bit imaging (a perfect copy of the original data). I can extract a ton of incredible data off of a crime scene, suspect, or victim and perfectly preserve it on drives, servers, or clouds fairly easily. Hooray!

So here’s the new issue: An incredible amount of my key evidence is now digital, I can acquire and preserve it with relative ease, and now I’m stuck here trying to figure out how to start looking through it. Aaaaand that’s terrible.

Evidence isn’t dying on the crime scene anymore. It’s dying on the agency’s servers, or on a USB drive in Detective Bob’s desk drawer.

With every day that passes by, that evidence becomes less and less influential on the course of the ongoing investigation. And don’t even get me started on the exponential loss of intelligence value…

Newly acquired gang, cartel, mafia, or terrorist organization information ages like a Chipotle burrito bowl. (Day 1 is a fiesta. Day 2 is acceptable. Day 3 is a nightmare.)

The fix

It’s not easy. Short version: we (trainers, advisors, tool developers) need to make it easier for all investigators (not just your computer wiz kids) to go through mass digital evidence to solve their cases.

Please understand that this is not turning every detective into a scientist-grade digital forensic examiner who starts every sentence with “Well, it actually depends…”

If we’re going to live in a pleasant society in 2027 where a reasonable number of cases are solved, a detective should be able to Copenhagen and triage digital evidence reports at the same time.

There’s no magic button, there’s no way to motivate your people to search through raw data harder, and there’s no way to hire enough examiners or analysts to keep up.

This problem looks different everywhere, and the fix is different everywhere - and that’s exciting. If you don’t feel excitement when you’re looking down the barrel of this issue, I’d love to discuss it with you. I’ve been called a beacon of positivity by people who don’t know me well. Hit that Contact button wherever it is.

[This post isn’t sponsored by Copenhagen, but I’m open to it. Reach out.]

More

All field notes

Seeing this in your agency?

Let’s find where it stalls.

Get in touch